The actor had internet sleuths investigating after he showed up to the Vanity Fair Oscars party sporting the same accessory as his co-star in the Blake Lively summer movie currently at the center of a legal dispute.

... Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni, who are currently embroiled in a very public legal battle. Let's go back to the red carpet premiere of It Ends with Us — specifically, Justin's outfit at the time. He wore a rose pin on the lapel of his suit jacket, which you can see below.

Brandon Sklenar told PEOPLE at the SXSW premiere of his film 'Drop' that wearing the same brooch as Justin Baldoni at an Oscars afterparty 'was a total happenstance.'