Log cabins have roots in Scandinavia and Eastern Europe, dating as far back as 3,500 B.C., followed by European settlers constructing these primitive homes in America starting in the 17th century.

“When people walk in the door, I don’t want them to know when they are or where they are,” says Jessie McLaughlin of the whimsical log cabin she reimagined in North Carolina. “I really want it to feel ...